rimlike/memory.md
megaproxy c5dadedab0 Bump MVP map to 80², lock world-view camera, resolve doc rot
Resolves the rimlike docs audit. Decisions made this session:

- Map: 40² → 80² for MVP slice; architecture sized to ~120² ceiling.
  Pawn count unchanged (3 start / 6 cap) — 'split-the-difference'
  sizing rather than frontier-feel scale.
- World-view camera (locked): pinch + drag-pan + double-tap-centre.
  Storyteller alerts include 'Go there' tap. No minimap, no
  follow-cam in MVP. New ui.md section captures this.
- Storyteller cooldowns: per-event AND per-category — both gates
  must pass. Resolves design.md/architecture.md disagreement.
- MAX_STACKS_PER_THOUGHT = 5 (was named-but-unset).
- Hauling no-destination fallback: drop after 3 retry passes,
  surface a passive 'No stockpile accepts X' alert.
- Container all-neighbors-blocked: hold then drop after ~5 sim s
  to avoid deadlock.
- Auto-roof big-room UX: emits room_too_large signal when BFS hits
  the ≤8-cell cap; UI surfaces a 'split with an interior wall'
  banner. Threshold + exact wording added to memory.md TODOs.

Doc rot cleaned in design.md and architecture.md: removed the stale
'8 work categories' intermediate sections (canonical 9-list lives
later in each file). Updated architecture.md perf claims for the new
map size.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
2026-05-10 19:45:29 +01:00

17 KiB
Raw Blame History

memory — rimlike

Durable memory for this project. Read at session start, update before session end. Date format: YYYY-MM-DD.

A 2D, tile-based cute-farming-RPG-meets-colony-sim — Rimworld DNA, Going Medieval × Stardew lodestars — shaped for mobile and handheld. Promoted from ~/claude/ideas/rimlike on 2026-05-10 after a single deep brainstorm session. Realistic MVP timeline: 36 months solo.

How to read this project

memory.md is the index of decisions and open questions. The deep specs live alongside in docs/:

File Contents
docs/design.md Game design — core loop, simplifications, skills, statuses, mood, weather, stockpiles, production, combat, death/burial, storyteller corpus
docs/architecture.md Tech — pawn AI / job system, time/tick model, Godot 4 engine layout, TileMap split, all subsystems (mood, lighting, rooms, hauling, production, combat, storyteller)
docs/ui.md Touch UX — work-priority matrix, stockpile/container screens, mood/lighting/rooms cues, combat banners, storyteller event UI, screens still to design
docs/art.md Owned assets (ElvGames bundle primary, Ventilatore secondary), license, autotile gotcha, audit list, candidates kept for record

When working on a feature, read memory.md first, then the relevant docs/ file(s).

Decisions & rationale

Distilled from the brainstorm. Each lock has a "why" — change with deliberate intent.

Pillars

Decision Choice Why
View Top-down, grid-aligned tilemap Closest to Rimworld feel; matches owned tilesets.
Primary platforms iOS + Android touch, then Steam Deck / ROG Ally gamepad. Desktop falls out for free. Mobile is the hard constraint; Deck inherits.
Ambition itch.io + TestFlight release. Real artifact, small audience. Drives engine choice; no app-store polish-tax.
Engine Godot 4 (GDScript) 2D-first, free, exports everywhere we need, fast iteration.
Tile size / style 16×16 pixel art, cute-farming-RPG primary (ElvGames bundle), Ventilatore as medieval accent ElvGames "Ultimate Farming RPG" Humble bundle owned (~2.8 GB, 70+ packs). Tone: Stardew × Going Medieval × Rimworld.
Setting Medieval fantasy with cute palette Owned-art alignment + clearer scope (no electricity / hydroponics / energy weapons) + underexplored on mobile.
Run shape Open-ended sandbox, autosave, persistent world Player picks up where they left off.
Session length 515 min target Drives every UI and pacing choice.
Default speed Fast (5×), with auto-pause on event 1 in-game day ≈ 5 min real time. Solves the "watch a pawn walk for 60s" problem; 1× exists for combat / fine work.
Goal scaffolding Light storyteller prompts Soft, dismissible nudges give each short session shape without forcing scenarios.
Combat Realtime with auto-pause on threat Rimworld-feel; touch-friendly.
Health Single HP per pawn + status effects (Bleeding/Sick/Tired/Hungry/Wet/Cold/Downed/...) ~80% of the drama for ~5% of Rimworld's health-system code.
Scale 36 pawns, 80×80 MVP map (architecture sized to ~120² ceiling) Roughly Stardew-farm size; readable when zoomed in, doesn't fit a phone screen — forces the world-view camera (pinch / pan / jump-to-alert) rather than strategic-overview-on-phone.
Priority levels 5 (Critical / High / Normal / When idle / Off) Matches Rimworld + Going Medieval contract.
Failure state Ghost colony — no game over; storyteller drops wanderer in 35 days Mobile-friendly; preserves player investment.

Architecture (tech)

  • Sim tick 20 Hz, render 60 Hz, decoupled. Pawn positions lerp between sim ticks. (docs/architecture.md Time / tick model)
  • Pawn AI: 5-layer pipeline (Decision → WorkProvider → Job + JobRunner → Status interrupts → Player overrides). Slimmer than Rimworld's ThinkTree. ~8001500 LOC GDScript for full MVP.
  • TileMap layers: 0 Terrain · 1 Floor · 2 Wall · 3 Designation · 4 Roof · 5 Fog. Furniture / Pawn / Item / EffectFX as scene-instanced entities (not TileMap).
  • Pathfinding: AStarGrid2D (built-in), updated on wall/door/furniture changes.
  • No background simulation — app backgrounded = sim paused. Avoids "lost colony to a raid while at work."
  • Save format: between sim ticks only; JobRunner mid-toil state round-trips from day one.

Game design

  • 5 skills (Manual Labor / Crafting / Cooking / Medicine / Combat), 010 each, level by use, multiplicative speed/quality bonus. Skills modify duration and quality, never permission.
  • 9 work categories (Construction / Mining / Hauling / Cleaning / Crafting / Cooking / Plant / Doctor / Combat). 5-level priority matrix per pawn.
  • Storage: floor zones AND independent crate furniture (4 stacks each), unified by StorageDestination interface. 16 filter chips (Wd/St/Ir/Cu/Ag/Au/Cl/Veg/Mt/Gr/Ck/Md/Tl/Wp/Ar/Co), 5 priorities with Rimworld flow semantics. One stack per tile, one type per tile.
  • Production: 2-step where medieval-sense (Iron→Ingot→Weapon, Grain→Flour→Bread); 1-step otherwise. 5 workbenches (Carpenter, Smelter, Smithy, Cooking hearth, Millstone), ~22 recipes. Full Rimworld bill semantics (one-shot count / forever / until-N + ingredient-quality filter + skill threshold).
  • Quality system (Shoddy/Normal/Excellent/Masterwork/Legendary) on every crafted item; multiplicative stat bonus. Quality from crafter skill + RNG only (inputs are just resources).
  • Mood: ~13 thoughts (data-driven registry, mix persistent + event-driven). Soft breaks at sustained mood < 25 for 30 in-game min — Sulking or Wandering, recover at mood ≥ 35.
  • Lighting (real shader at night), auto-detected rooms (named by furniture, scored for beauty + dirtiness), dirtiness + Cleaning (8th work category), beauty score with Quality multiplier.
  • Roofing: indoor = Layer-4 Roof flag, sim-data only (no rendering, just an indoor tint on floors). Auto-roof when walls enclose ≤8 cells (BFS); No-Roof designation for courtyards. Plants don't grow indoors.
  • Weather: 4 types (Clear / Rain / Storm / Cold snap), daily roll, season-weighted. Wet status accumulates outside in rain, decays indoors. 4 seasons × 12 days = 48-day year.
  • Combat: 3 weapons (sword/axe/bow), 3 armor slots (helm/cuirass/boots). Walls + trees provide cover. Two-roll resolution (hit, then damage with armor reduction). Downed-then-rescue death model; doctors auto-prioritize. Combat=Off "defends if cornered, won't volunteer." Friendly fire ON.
  • Death / corpses: Both burial AND cremation. Graveyard = special stockpile (Corpses-only); pawns dig graves, place permanent grave markers (tap → deceased pawn-detail). Cremation pyre = furniture with single recipe (1 corpse + 5 wood). Corpses decay 050 fresh / 50100 rotting (no butcher) / 100 rotted.
  • Storyteller: 25 prompts written in docs/design.md. Daily 6am roll, weighted pool, per-category cooldowns, tension model alternates quiet/threat per Tynan Sylvester pacing. Ambient banner for low-stakes, modal auto-pause for choice events.

Touch UX

  • Bottom-sheet menus instead of right-side panels. Long-press = inspect/context. Tap world = select. Speed/pause buttons fixed top.
  • Work-priority matrix: 9 columns × N pawns, sticky pawn-name column, horizontal scroll on phone. Tap-to-cycle priority, long-press for 5-chip picker, swipe column for bulk-set. Per-pawn and per-job views layered on top.
  • Stockpile/container UI: 4×4 chip grid for the 16 filter categories; same UI for floor zones and crates.
  • Storyteller events: ambient banners for nudges/seasonal/lore; modal auto-pause for wanderer/threat/disease/milestone. Events log + "while you were away" digest at resume.
  • Indoor tint marks "this is inside" without needing roof rendering — matches Stardew/Rimworld convention.
  • World-view camera: pinch-zoom + drag-pan + double-tap-to-center; selected pawn does not force-follow. Storyteller alerts/banners include a Go there tap that pans the camera to the event tile. No minimap in MVP — revisit if playtest shows people getting lost on the 80² map.

Art strategy

  • ElvGames "Ultimate Farming RPG" Humble bundle is the primary art (/mnt/d/godot/assets/humble set new/, ~2.8 GB, 70+ packs, all 16×16, ElvGames license: commercial OK with credit).
  • Ventilatore Fantasy Tileset Complete Bundle stays as medieval accent for biome variety / decorative props / animated water.
  • Mana Seed series considered but dropped from buy plan (the bundle covers what we'd planned).
  • Authoring still required: designation overlays (~2 hrs custom), possibly autotile bits on bundle wall sheets, possibly wolf sprite, possibly grave marker.

Open questions / TODOs

Audit / unblock-the-prototype action items

These are concrete checks to run before serious construction begins. Total ~75 min.

  • Aesthetic harmony test — open one tile from ElvGames Forest 4 Seasons + one from Ventilatore + view side-by-side. Decide whether they mesh (use both) or clash (drop Ventilatore from active use). ~15 min.
  • ElvGames autotile audit — count corner / T-junction / cap pieces in Houses Tileset 2 Seasons/FG_Houses.png and Fortress Tileset 2 Seasons/FG_Fortress.png. ≥16 wall variants per material → autotile is solvable; <8 → fall back to Mana Seed Iconic Homestead ($19.99) or custom-author. ~1530 min.
  • Wolf sprite source — bundle's Animal Sprites pack lacks wolves. Browse EvoMonster Packs 0115 or Turn-Based RPG Monster packs for a suitable predator. Or plan custom (~few hours pixel art). ~15 min.
  • Grave marker source — Retro Graveyard 16×16 (Tier 3) probably has it; verify. ~10 min.
  • License compilation — maintain credits string for every pack used (ElvGames + Ventilatore + any others). Display in game's credits screen. Confirm specific terms per pack before any commercial release.

Design topics still open

  • Auto-roof big-room UX: the ≤8-cell BFS cap silently fails on rooms larger than 8×8. Decide whether to (a) keep the cap and surface "this area is too large to roof — split with an interior wall" hint when the player encloses one, (b) bump the cap to ~16 with the same hint at the new threshold, or (c) detect any enclosed area regardless of size. Affects EnclosureDetector + a new room-feedback UI.
  • Onboarding / first 60 seconds: mobile-specific. Don't copy Rimworld's tutorial.
  • Touch UI for non-priority screens: world view, build drawer, alerts, day-summary, pawn detail. See docs/ui.md "Screens still to design."
  • Background time / "while you were away" mechanic — locked to no background simulation in MVP; revisit if it feels bad in playtest.
  • Audio direction — who/where for SFX + ambient track? Bundle has 11 music + 8 SFX packs covering most needs.
  • Steam Deck input parity — gamepad-driven cursor, or full menu navigation by D-pad? Probably both.
  • Localization stance — English-only for MVP, but architect strings for i18n (already locked in CLAUDE.md).
  • Pawn name/backstory generation — hand-curated list vs simple generator.
  • Naming the game — "rimlike" is a working title.
  • Monetization stance — free? PWYW? Premium?
  • Tech / research progression — medieval tech tree shape.
  • Map / world generation — fixed seed for slice; procgen later.

Tunable in prototype (not real "open Qs", just numbers to playtest)

  • Sleep mood gradient values (+5/+0/2/5/8)
  • Wet status thresholds (25 / 60) and accumulation rates
  • Season weather weights (Spring/Summer/Autumn/Winter distributions)
  • Hit-chance bonuses (skill ×5%, range ×5%, cover 40/20%)
  • Bleed-out timer (6 in-game hours)
  • Various mood thought magnitudes and decay times

Vertical slice (MVP target)

Same scope as locked in ~/claude/ideas/rimlike/plan.md. Realistic timeline 36 months solo for an MVP this rich.

  • 1 biome (temperate forest, ElvGames Forest Tileset 4 Seasons; Ventilatore foliage accents).
  • 1 map, 80×80 tiles, fixed seed for now.
  • 3 starting pawns ("settlers" / "villagers"), each with name + portrait + one-sentence backstory.
  • Verbs: chop wood, mine stone & ore, build walls/floors/furniture/crates, plant/harvest crops (34 types), cook meals (recipes), haul, repair, clean.
  • Needs: hunger, sleep, mood (~13 distinct thoughts, soft breaks at sustained mood < 25).
  • Status effects: Hungry, Tired, Bleeding, Sick, Downed, Wet (Damp/Soaked), Cold.
  • Storage: floor zones AND containers, 16 filter chips, 5 priorities.
  • Quality system on all crafted items.
  • Lighting — torches + hearths emit light; visual darkness at night.
  • Rooms — auto-detected, named by contents, beauty + dirtiness scored.
  • Cleaning as 8th work category.
  • Day/night cycle, ~5 min per day at default speed. Seasons (Spring/Summer/Autumn/Winter, 12 days each).
  • Weather: Clear / Rain / Storm / Cold snap.
  • One disaster type: wolves at night (bandit raids deferred).
  • One storyteller: random quiet/threat alternation, 25 prompt corpus.
  • Save/load, autosave on suspend, single slot.
  • Touch UI end-to-end (no desktop-only gestures).
  • Sound: minimal — UI clicks, ambient day/night loop, alert sting.

Session log

2026-05-10

  • Promoted from ~/claude/ideas/rimlike/ (single multi-hour brainstorm session).
  • Scaffolded projects/rimlike/ from _templates/project/. Customized CLAUDE.md. Distilled plan.md into this memory.md. Moved companion files (design / architecture / ui / art) into docs/. git init, first commit "Initial scaffold". Created Forgejo repo rimlike (private), set HTTPS remote, pushed main. Archived idea folder to ~/claude/archive/ideas/rimlike/.
  • Wired Godot MCP Pro: .mcp.json, .claude/settings.local.json allowlist, three project-local subagents (quick-edit, researcher, gdscript-refactor). Added the MCP-Pro and tiered-delegation sections to CLAUDE.md. Editor plugin / addons/godot_mcp/ re-copy still pending Godot project scaffold.
  • Reviewed docs/ against memory.md and CLAUDE.md. Decisions made:
    • Map size bumped from 40² → 80² for the MVP slice; architecture sized to ~120² ceiling. Pawn count stays at 3 start / 6 cap (frontier feel was rejected in favor of "split-the-difference" sizing — Stardew-farm scale, not Going-Medieval scale).
    • World-view camera = pinch-zoom + drag-pan + double-tap-to-center; storyteller alerts include a Go there tap. No minimap in MVP. No follow-cam (avoids fighting the player when issuing build orders across the map).
    • Storyteller cooldown semantics: per-event AND per-category, both gates must pass (resolves the design.md vs architecture.md disagreement).
    • MAX_STACKS_PER_THOUGHT = 5 (was named-but-unset).
    • Hauling-loop fallback: items that fail to find any valid destination after 3 retry passes drop on the floor and surface as a passive "No stockpile accepts X" alert.
  • Cleaned up doc rot in docs/design.md and docs/architecture.md — both had stale "8 work categories" intermediate sections still next to the canonical "9" lists. Removed the (8) snapshots.
  • Updated docs/architecture.md perf assumptions (60² → 80² with 120² ceiling).
  • docs/ui.md got a new World view camera (locked) section; removed the world-view bullet from "Screens still to design".
  • Open: auto-roof big-room UX (added to TODOs above) — the ≤8-cell BFS cap silently fails on bigger rooms; player feedback path needs a decision before EnclosureDetector lands.

External references

  • Forgejo repo: https://git.rdx4.com/megaproxy/rimlike (private)
  • Owned art bundle (primary): ElvGames "Ultimate Farming RPG" Humble bundle, local at /mnt/d/godot/assets/humble set new/. License: ElvGames terms (https://elv-games.itch.io/terms). Commercial OK with credit; no NFT/crypto/resale.
  • Owned art bundle (secondary): Ventilatore Fantasy Tileset Complete Bundle — https://itch.io/s/117124/the-fantasy-tileset-complete-bundle
  • Mana Seed catalog (fallback if bundle gaps surface): https://seliel-the-shaper.itch.io/
  • Iconic Homestead (autotile-ready wall fallback, $19.99): https://seliel-the-shaper.itch.io/iconic-homestead
  • Lodestars: Rimworld (Tynan Sylvester / Ludeon Studios), Going Medieval (Foxy Voxel), Stardew Valley (ConcernedApe).
  • Original brainstorm history: archived to ~/claude/archive/ideas/rimlike/ after promotion. The session log there captures every decision's rationale.
  • Brainstorming-mode preference: see ~/.claude/projects/-home-megaproxy-claude-ideas/memory/brainstorm-ask-dont-decide.md (not directly applicable to projects but captures interaction style).